Categories

The Great Acting Blog: “Great Acting Is Wrought”

The Great Acting Blog: “Great Acting Is Wrought”

 

I recently watched a film which, by all accounts, I should have loved: the precise full frontal camerawork, the pared back narrative, “gaps” in the montage which encourages the viewer to create the film in his own imagination, and I am always interested in good protagonists who descend into moral turpitude as a result of tragedy. Despite these merits, something bugged me about it – I was never quite able to accept the film while I was watching it, and at times I even felt something akin to embarassment. I finally lost respect for it when, near the end, the protagonist solved his spiritual crisis by having a bit of a tantrum and a bit of a cry, then threatening to kill himself before his friend intervened. In the next scene his hair is washed (which indicates that his inner conflict has been resolved) and he is ready to return to his loved ones after his self-imposed exile.

 

The problem with this film is that there is no proper struggle on the part of the protagonist throughout the film to resolve his crisis – what we see is the pretence of a struggle –  and the reason is because there has been no struggle on the part of the filmmaker to create the film in the first place, only the pretence of struggle. My guess is the filmmakers studied the “hip” cinematography of the day, and the “hip” “issues” of the day, and constructed the film using a pic n mix of “hip” cinema, the goal of which is to supply a pre-determined effect. The trouble with this approach is that the results are alienating, because we feel, rightly, that the filmmaker is making assumptions about us in an effort to control what we think (it’s like the person who, in trying to extort an endorsement from us, posits a notion which is apparently unassailable because it is fashionable, or because it is oh-so-magnanimous, and assumes we’ll agree) – it’s when cinema becomes advertising. The filmmakers here are complacent, they are well educated and know which end of a camera to hold, so perhaps their goal is not to create a work of art, but to get us to admire them. What I am criticizing here is not their skills then, but their art. You cannot copy and paste art, whatever the form and no matter how skilled you may be – it is drawn from the strange, vague and inchoate feelings that lay beyond the outskirts of our consciousness, and the inner struggle is the struggle to bring forth those feelings and give them a form which makes them meaningful, first to ourselves, and then to other people. If there is no struggle then there is no true creation, and therefore no art.

 

Well, the good news for actors is that you can’t pic n mix your performance from other actors – your personality and the way you look are unique – there’s only one of you. However, the equivalent for an actor in terms of supplying a pre-determined effect is working out exactly how you are going to say the lines, and exactly which moves you are going to do and when, and simply step on stage or before the camera, and execute your preparation regardless of what is actually happening in the scene – the famous example of this is the actor who is playing a scene where they have to creep into a room making as little noise as possible, however, when they open the door it unexpectedly squeaks, but the actor ignores this because it wasn’t in the script, and continues to play the scene as it was rehearsed. This performance is not a performance at all, merely a reference to the work done in rehearsals, and it’s usually dull to watch regardless of how technically accomplished it may be, because nothing is being created in the moment. The exciting actor is the one who doesn’t know what is going to happen next, and possesses the will and the courage to face the truth of the moment as it presents itself. This kind of actor does not fall back on his preparation when the spooky unforseen upsets his apple cart, but struggles to come to terms with it as best he can – this is extremely hard work, and very different to some complacent, reasoned, hand-picking of pre-determined moments.

 

Great acting is wrought.

 

James

28Comments
  • James Devereaux/ 16.09.2011Reply

    Yes, completely agree with those fundamentals…Delighted to hear you trained with such a seminal figure in American theatre – I believe Brando did aswell, so it’s a wonderful lineage. Can’t image what being in a studio with her must have been like.

  • ponstel authentique en vente en ligne/ 05.08.2024Reply

    Realiza la compra de medicamentos en línea Mylan Zoutleeuw medicijnen online te
    koop zonder problemen

  • Goedkope berodual kopen in Nederland/ 06.08.2024Reply

    leki bez recepty w Hiszpanii sanias Saint-Germain-en-Laye Wo Medikamente ohne Rezept in Genf erhältlich ist – Empfehlungen

  • medrol en venta en Ecuador sin receta/ 13.08.2024Reply

    disponibilidad de medicamentos en México Pfizer Emmen comprar
    medicamentos en línea

  • pariet bei Migräne/ 17.08.2024Reply

    acquisto online di farmaci a Roma, Italia Normon Toledo medicijnen kopen voor snelle
    verlichting

  • ебля с двумя шлюхами/ 17.08.2024Reply

    проститутка света из перми порно видео звезд телевидения досуг для секса в москве минет в новокуйбышевске

  • comprar forimycin en México legalmente/ 19.08.2024Reply

    medicijnen te koop in Italië Medinsa Raaba is het mogelijk om medicijnen zonder voorschrift te krijgen

  • Kauf von betnovate online in Belgien/ 20.08.2024Reply

    compra farmaci a Napoli online Normon Chimay farmaci
    in vendita a Città del Messico

  • Online apotheek voor ofloxacin in Leiden/ 20.08.2024Reply

    Tabletas a precios bajos Aurobindo Oldenburg zakup leków online

  • donde comprar medicamentos en Chile Globo Ecatepec/ 21.08.2024Reply

    médicaments disponible en France ranbaxy Cimitile Acheter médicaments sans prescription médicale
    en France

  • prix du médicaments sans ordonnance teva Tumaco/ 23.08.2024Reply

    medicamentos sin receta en México ranbaxy Jodoigne acquista farmaci online a Roma senza necessità di
    ricetta

  • если снится что дерешься с мамой/ 24.08.2024Reply

    сонник он играет на скрипке сила таро да нет, карта таро судьба значение да-нет молитва на сотовый
    набора магическая битва сколько лет к чему снится,
    что муж собирает вещи и уходит,
    к чему снится муж жене

  • Kauf von voltfast in Deutschland/ 28.08.2024Reply

    achat de médicaments en pharmacie Heunet Reggio Emilia médicaments à
    bas prix

  • bolutol kopen goedkoopste/ 02.09.2024Reply

    medicijnen kopen online Nederland Vale Oudenburg Bestel
    medicijnen online en vermijd lange wachtrijen in de apotheek

  • жеті атасын білген ұл жеті жұрттың қамын жер слайд/ 06.09.2024Reply

    мен деп ойла ерген скачать, сатыбалды абу мен деп ойла газель бизнес
    цена в казахстане, купить газель в казахстане астанаға құттықтау хат,
    қала күнімен құттықтау хадж и умра что это,
    малый хадж умра цена

  • махамбеттің баймағамбет сұлтанға айтқаны кейіпкерлер/ 12.09.2024Reply

    мемлекеттік тіл туралы мақала, мемлекеттік тілді дамыту жоспары нейрон актау прайс лист, нейрон
    актау врачи осман империясы құрылған ғасыр, осман империясы хандары жүктілік кезінде қуықтың ашуы, жүктілік кезінде қан аралас выделение

  • cheese platters/ 13.09.2024Reply

    I am genuinely thankful to the holder of this web site who has shared this impressive post at here.

  • құрлық сулары қалай қалыптасады/ 14.09.2024Reply

    неліктен досыңыздың сүйіктісі бар деп армандайсыз?

    ежелгі қытай деректері, ежелгі қытай билеушілері атырауский инженерно-гуманитарный институт, евразийский гуманитарный институт расписание поездов
    капчагай, расписание электрички капчагай – алматы

  • best ways to use pink and blue in photographs/ 14.09.2024Reply

    Article writing is also a excitement, if you be familiar with afterward you can write if not it is
    complicated to write.

  • қар қандай/ 16.09.2024Reply

    казак радиосы алматы, шалқар
    радиосы құттықтау телефон ағылшынша төл сөзге мысал, төлеу сөзге 5 мысал арыс – аксу, актобе
    чемпион лучший педиатр алматы отзывы, педиатр алматы круглосуточно

  • Seoladh tapa telfast 180 mg/ 16.09.2024Reply

    I’m excited to find this web site. I need to to thank you for ones time for this particularly wonderful read!!
    I definitely appreciated every little bit of it and I have you saved to fav to check out new stuff on your site.

  • спандияр көбеев тәрбие сағаты қмж/ 18.09.2024Reply

    сұлулық әлемі скачать мазмұндама 3 сынып көшет, мазмұндама 3 сынып балапан квадратный трехчлен решение, найти корни квадратного трехчлена калькулятор ұйқы келе берсе, адам
    неге ұйықтай береді

  • исток аудио казахстан/ 30.09.2024Reply

    күн бізден қаншалықты алыс орналасқан,
    жұлдыздардың шынайы жарқырауын қалай анықтайды орыс әдебиеті мен орыс реализмнің негізін салушы, орыс ақындарының өлеңдері алматы
    – достык, поезд алматы достык отзывы долгосрочная
    аренда квартир в кызылорде, аренда квартир кызылорда

  • мұхтар әуезов естелік-эссе/ 04.10.2024Reply

    сайт құрылымы деген не,
    web парақ дегеніміз не ақ бидай ертегісі, ақ бидай
    мазмұндама 4 сынып дұрыс әдеби тіл, әдеби тіл жүйелі тіл википедия – это,
    википедия не работает

  • Melissa Hiz/ 04.10.2024Reply

    My site UQ6 covers a lot of topics about Cosmetic Treatment and I thought we could greatly benefit from each other. Awesome posts by the way!

  • әлемде жоқ жануар әдістемесінің интерпретациясы/ 06.10.2024Reply

    екі тілді мемлекеттер, екі тілді білген екі адам эссе
    как получить сертификат воспитателя детского сада, курсы воспитателя детского сада цена астер авто тараз номер телефона, рассрочка авто тараз теңдессіз жау темекі тәрбие сағаты, шылым шегудің зияны тәрбие сағаты

  • гадание напишет или нет мужчина сегодня/ 13.10.2024Reply

    к чему снится что пожар на улице к чему снится занять денег в долг сказки для детей 7 лет слушать бесплатно, аудиосказки для детей 7-8 лет
    во сне ехать в автобусе сидя, сон ехать в автобусе пассажиром к чему
    сниться стержень

  • чудеса молитвы богородице дево/ 20.10.2024Reply

    петренко по гороскопу повешенный значение таро тота отшельник и тройка пентаклей сочетание таро
    русские приметы, хорошие русские приметы приснился
    сад яблоневый сад

Leave a Comment