The Great Acting Blog: “Exclude The Meaningless”
Devil And The Deep is an old Marion Gering film from 1932, and stars Charles Laughton as a submarine commander who is insanely jealous of any attention given to his wife, played by Tallulah Bankhead, so insanely jealous infact, that he drives her into the arms of his first officer, Gary Cooper. The film is a model of simplicity and precision, in contrast to much of contemporary cinema which is so often drenched in design and camerawork, that it’s difficult to see the film itself. Not so Devil And The Deep – everything is in service of the film. The story is told economically, using largely static shots, uninflected and objective, without explanations like handheld camera work (which so often for me, indicates a lack of conviction on the part of the filmmaker), Gering and his crew don’t explain the film to us, they simply let it take place, thus allowing us to participate and create the film for ourselves. So, the filmmaking in Devil And The Deep, has a wonderful combination of humility and beauty. And in terms of the performances, I finally came to understand something which I have felt but never really been able to articulate about minmalism in film acting.
Now, the art and craft of acting has been in steady decline over the last 50 or 60 years, even to the point where famous directors publicly denigrate the form (“I hate actors and their bag of tricks”), and we’ve got movie stars openly ridiculing acting while simultaneously trousering millions of dollars. Any attempt at a serious discussion about acting is derided as pretentious, and actors have their “value” measured by whether they have been successful in the industrial arena as oppose to the artistic. The acting in Devil And The Deep is sublime, especially from Laughton: the extraneous is cut away and only the essential is included, so that what we see is a precise, true and vivid performance, shockingly vivid at times, and further, every movement serves a precise purpose (much like the script and camerawork). Laughton’s performance delights and compels us, and his generosity is enormous – as when we hear his garrulous laugh after catching only the punchline to his jokes – he warms us, like a log fire does. In short: Laughton is truly expressing himself. It’s the sort of performance that today would be dismissed as “stagey”, and Laughton ridiculed as a mere “luvvie”. Why? Because he does not subscribe to the pinchfistedness laughingly described as “naturalism”. But I say this “naturalism” – the fidgeting, and the meaningless gesturing, the fake stuttering (which is an artificial affectation applied by the actor) is a repression of a crucial aspect of human nature, ie – to play, to perform, to express, to try other people’s clothes on – and in attempting to repress it, we are infact attempting to repress the truth, and in it’s place we put the crocodile tears and verisimilitude of “naturalism”, and wrap it up in do-gooderism in order to justify the lie. But performing is an essential aspect of our lives, that’s why actors exist: TO PERFORM, hence we write scripts, build stages, and turn our cameras upon them in order for them to do so. Why deny it? Why repress this need to see the drama of our lives played out infront of us? Why pretend that what we are witnessing is not a performance? Do ballerinas pretend they’re not dancing? The irony of minimalist acting in cinema is that it is theatrical, and the more minimal it is the more theatrical it is. I think of great filmmakers like Yashujiro Ozu, or Robert Bresson, or Aki Kaurismaki, (the acting in whose films is often quite brilliant) who ask their actors to pare back their performances in order to serve the film, and to exclude the meaningless. But what is this paring back? This exclusion of the meaningless? It is a cutting away of the non-essential, and in so doing, a theatrical style of film acting is brought forth, it draws attention to the fact that the actor is performing, afterall, he is supposed to be performing – that’s the whole point – what we see infront of us is a deliberate creation, a deliberate arrangement, a work of art, and, as such, we, the audience, witness performances of great beauty, and which bring us great joy.
|
Mick Cahill/ 05.08.2011
"Now, the art and craft of acting has been in steady decline over the last 50 or 60 years" No James, it hasn’t. It has, at least in film and TV, become slightly diluted, but there are as many good actors now as there have ever been. As for criticism of actors (I note yours are uncredited) Hitchcock famously described actors as "cattle" 60 years ago and we all know how they were regarded in the 16th Century.That there has been an evolution in performance style from the time of Laughton to the time of Hackman (I haven’t thought about this long, but I think their oeuvres are comparable) is undeniable – but if there has been a loss in the quality of film performances I would say that is nothing to do with the actors and everything to do with directors today having yet to reach the level of visual fluency which their predecessors in the 1920’s had reached before the advent of sound.That the notion of "naturalism" is just a notion; I do not deny. The unholy trinity of Stanislavsky/Meisner/Strasberg has served up some appalling, tick laden, mumbling crap in the last 50 years. And I agree with the implicit argument you present that theatre acting and film acting are not, as is popularly presented these days, different. But I do disagree with your contention that they did it ‘better’ 70 years ago. The declamatory, performative, style of the 1930’s had its merits, and is entertaining, but it could not serve the stories we now tell. The fact is that acting on the stage, now, has also changed. Because of film and television audiences now look for the performance rather than expecting it to be thrown at them. I have much more to say but it’s very late here so I will leave you with this incomplete missive. But, Mr Devereaux, I am very impressed by the seriousness of your research and argument. Adieu.
relaxing jazz music/ 10.10.2023
relaxing jazz music
piano jazz music/ 29.11.2023
piano jazz music
zakup prinivil w Łodzi online/ 16.08.2024
Kauf von schlaffördernden Medikamenten Betapharm Damme farmacia de medicamentos
яндекс русдосуг/ 18.08.2024
индивидуалки владикавказа фото секс знакомство в оренбурге с женщинами проститутки москвы подруги
проститутки девки шлюхи
dafiro ohne ärztliche Verschreibung online bestellen/ 18.08.2024
Preise für Medikamente ohne Rezept Fortbenton Aracataca medicamentos con o sin prescripción médica
сонник бывший нападает/ 04.09.2024
можно ли трогать карты таро другим людям,
как очистить карты таро если их трогали что делать если снится умершие
родственники комиксы по соннику читать онлайн
что снится е смерти возобновятся ли отношения таро онлайн
landscape photography composition/ 05.09.2024
Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet
my newest twitter updates. I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and
was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this.
Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to
your new updates.
สโบเบทกับรางวัลการันตีความมั่นคง/ 06.09.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Info to that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
казииту уральск стоимость обучения/ 07.09.2024
заключить брак онлайн прикол, регистрация брака онлайн украина 2022 ботокс желудка
алматы, шунтирование желудка астана бүлін
сөз тіркесі, етістікті сөз тіркесі
мысал келер шақ тапсырмалар, осы шақ өткен шақ келер шақ
ағылшынша
คาสิโนออนไลน์ คาสิโนสด คืออะไร/ 09.09.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] There you will find 79906 additional Info on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
аке туралы эссе 2 сынып/ 11.09.2024
elc astana, interpress kazakhstan электротовары для дома, электрокомплекс
алматы адреса абая туркебаева жк, жк кристалл крыша
дипломная работа в рассрочку, дипломная работа
образец
ссс арабская компания атырау контакты/ 16.09.2024
қазақ тілі сабағына талдау жасау, сабақты талдау критерийлері а-позиция оболочка, черепица цена алматы олх купить
машину через каспи, каспи автокредит
условия 9 сынып информатика тест сұрақтары жауаптарымен,
информатика тест 9 сынып 1 токсан
มวยพักยก เว็บแทงมวย อันดับหนึ่ง/ 16.09.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Here you will find 38126 more Information to that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
online aankoop van noriline in Spanje/ 19.09.2024
Medikamente ohne Rezept in Frankfurt, Deutschland Fannin Susteren farmaci originale
in vendita online
Einkauf von decadron in Deutschland/ 20.09.2024
medicamentos a precio asequible en Santiago Nepenthes Sistrans medicijnen met of zonder voorschrift
in Frankrijk
Continue/ 02.10.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] There you can find 91170 more Info on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
E699/ 08.10.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
мәңгілік бала бейне кейіпкерлері/ 09.10.2024
grandfish, форелевое хозяйство ермаковка купить футболку с
национальной символикой, футболка казахстан костанай ағзаның сұйық ортасы, ағзаның ішкі ортасы
тест тасымалдап жазу түйеқұс
marbo 9k/ 15.10.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More here to that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
JILISLOT/ 21.10.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More on on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
เกียรติบัตรออนไลน์/ 24.10.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
азаматтық құқықтық қатынастар/ 24.10.2024
бэби клиник астана, бэби клиник астана мангилик ел сульфаниламидтер, сульфаниламидтік препараттар справочная тараз телефон, жд вокзал телефон справочная список вредных профессий в
казахстане адилет, вредные условия труда тк рк
преимущества работы на дому/ 02.11.2024
подработка уборщиком в туле хорошая подработка красноярск ищу подработку
женщина в москве подработка на своей
газели тент
удаленная работа на дому балаково вакансии/ 04.11.2024
заявление на работу дома подработка на компьютере на дому со свободным графиком на чем можно заработать деньги без вложений подработка
номинальным директором спб
lottorich28/ 12.11.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] There you can find 66037 additional Info on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-exclude-the-meaningless/ […]
балабақша психологының диагностикасы/ 20.11.2024
уакыт бага жетпес кундылык эссе, мен уақытты бағындыра
аламын эссе дина нұрпейісова туған жылы, дина
нұрпейісова руы алюминий мен мырыштан тұратын массасы 2 г, массасы 30 г мыс пен
алюминий қоспасына концентрлі что относится к запасам в бухучете, учет запасов на предприятии