Categories

The Great Acting Blog: “Courageous Acting”

The Great Acting Blog: “Courageous Acting”

The obsession with “doing emotions” in modern acting is little short of a disaster. It paints the character (and therefore the actor) as a victim, stripping him of dignity. Further, when an actor tries to squeeze emotion out of themselves, they turn inward rather than outward and so exclude the audience, thus defeating the actor’s key task of communication. Emotion is bad storytelling because it’s vague, it diffuses strong, precise action. It often becomes a form of showcase, bastardising the actor’s performance, and this is especially true among actors who have a knack for turning on the waterworks, leading to; “oh look, he’s really crying” – so it’s bad art too, because it lacks aesthetic integrity. Above all, it’s just false, a lie.

Unfortunately, emotion dominates contemporary acting because it is seen as the signifier of quality, the more emotional an actor can be, then the more talented he is thought to be. Of course it’s complete nonsense, and even a cursory glance at the great actors of the Golden Years of Hollywood (Bogart, Cary Grant, Rita Hayworth etc) will tell us that. Actors at that time eschewed emotionalism, offering dignity, strength, simplicity, generosity and wit instead. There are exceptions today of course, most notably in the work of Finnish maestro, Aki Kaurismaki, but otherwise the tendency to emotion abounds. It’s hard to know when this shift occurred, perhaps it grew out of Method Acting, a technique which fetishises emotion, in the middle of the twentieth century. Perhaps, because Method actors gained such a good reputation (eg – Al Pacino), everyone thought they had to be emotional in order to be respected. Or perhaps it’s linked to the modern trend of “confessing”, of just letting it all hang loose, of telling the world your problems, of “it’s ok to show your feelings”. Whatever the roots are, I don’t care, a technique of acting based on emotion leads to false, weak, vague, self-conscious work.

Emotion in the actor’s performance is only true when it is organically produced by the actor’s attempts to do the action. Even then, it is a trivial by-product which the actor should not concern himself with – it is not the object of his work, that’s to tell the story. To withhold emotion, to exercise refrain, is to maintain dignity – that’s the mark of the courageous actor.

 

Subscribe to The Great Acting Blog

James

83Comments
  • Richard/ 23.11.2013Reply

    its just got to be truthful really, whatever comes out, a tear or not, a shout if angry or not..truthful stuff rings home in my opinion, forced hysterics is obviously not truthful, i dhtink the method was more about doing physical actions to arrive at emotion or character rather than fetishising emotions

    • Talya/ 08.12.2013Reply

      You are so right about that. I am always truthful in auditions and casting. After studying Meisner I cannot be truthful.

  • Kara/ 23.01.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com owner, You always provide great insights.

  • Wilbert/ 03.02.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com admin, Thanks for the post!

  • Levi/ 03.02.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com owner, Your posts are always well written.

  • Rosario/ 05.02.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com administrator, You always provide great information and insights.

  • Werner/ 05.02.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com admin, Thanks for the well-researched and well-written post!

  • Mercedes/ 06.02.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always well-cited and reliable.

  • Ivy/ 10.02.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always well-formatted and easy to read.

  • Lorrine/ 10.02.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Your posts are always well-supported by research and data.

  • Kristen/ 12.02.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com owner, Great post!

  • Matthias/ 12.02.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com owner, Your posts are always well-written and engaging.

  • Carissa/ 20.02.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Nice post!

  • Will/ 20.02.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Thanks for the well-organized post!

  • Jermaine/ 27.02.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, You always provide clear explanations and step-by-step instructions.

  • Tyson/ 27.02.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Thanks for the comprehensive post!

  • Julieta/ 28.02.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Thanks for the well-presented post!

  • Marcos/ 07.03.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Good job!

  • Noble/ 10.03.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com owner, You always provide useful links and resources.

  • Tayla/ 15.03.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com owner, You always provide great examples and real-world applications.

  • Fae/ 23.03.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Thanks for the well-researched and well-written post!

  • Shayne/ 23.03.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com owner, Your posts are always well organized and easy to understand.

  • Eusebia/ 25.03.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always on topic and relevant.

  • Tiffiny/ 25.03.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com admin, Your posts are always well researched and well written.

  • Ruben/ 27.03.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com owner, You always provide helpful diagrams and illustrations.

  • Debra/ 28.03.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com admin, Your posts are always well-referenced and credible.

  • Brianne/ 28.03.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com admin, Your posts are always well-written and easy to understand.

  • Lindsay/ 29.03.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Keep up the good work, admin!

  • Anton/ 29.03.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Your posts are always well-received by the community.

  • Zak/ 29.03.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always well-supported by research and data.

  • Corrine/ 29.03.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com administrator, You always provide valuable feedback and suggestions.

  • Leandro/ 01.04.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com administrator, You always provide great examples and real-world applications.

  • Shana/ 04.04.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com owner, Keep up the great work!

  • Noe/ 04.04.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Your posts are always well researched.

  • Jessica/ 05.04.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com administrator, You always provide useful links and resources.

  • Susanne/ 07.04.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Thanks for the valuable information!

  • Lester/ 10.04.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always on point.

  • Charla/ 13.04.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Keep up the great work!

  • Marlys/ 15.04.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Your posts are always well-written and engaging.

  • Annis/ 20.04.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Your posts are always well-referenced and credible.

  • Fay/ 16.05.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com admin, Thanks for the comprehensive post!

  • Art/ 08.06.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Thanks for the well-presented post!

  • Delia/ 17.07.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com owner, Keep up the good work!

  • Micah/ 14.08.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always well-formatted and easy to read.

  • Taylor/ 12.10.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com owner, Your posts are always well-structured and logical.

  • Eden/ 21.10.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com admin, Your posts are always well-timed and relevant.

  • Dolores/ 26.10.2023Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com admin, Great post!

  • Alice/ 31.10.2023Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Your posts are always informative and well-explained.

  • Justina/ 31.10.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com admin, You always provide clear explanations and step-by-step instructions.

  • Rayford/ 07.11.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Excellent work!

  • Silvia/ 13.11.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Great job!

  • James/ 15.12.2023Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com owner, Your posts are always well-formatted and easy to read.

  • Carmelo/ 22.12.2023Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always on point.

  • Ivey/ 01.01.2024Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Thanks for the well-organized and comprehensive post!

  • Darwin/ 08.01.2024Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always a great source of knowledge.

  • Rene/ 10.01.2024Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com admin, Well done!

  • Mickie/ 11.01.2024Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Thanks for the valuable information!

  • avatar

    view more/ 03.03.2024Reply

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-courageous-acting/ […]

  • Marion/ 19.05.2024Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com admin, Good to see your posts!

  • Sal/ 22.05.2024Reply

    Dear jamesdevereaux.com owner, Thanks for the informative post!

  • Kelly/ 24.05.2024Reply

    Hi jamesdevereaux.com webmaster, Good to see your posts!

  • Rosa/ 26.05.2024Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com administrator, Your posts are always well written.

  • Romeo/ 29.05.2024Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com admin, Thanks for the well-organized and comprehensive post!

  • Nellie/ 24.06.2024Reply

    Hello jamesdevereaux.com admin, Your posts are always well organized and easy to understand.

  • Kristeen/ 22.07.2024Reply

    To the jamesdevereaux.com admin, You always provide clear explanations and step-by-step instructions.

  • Sergpaisa/ 04.08.2024Reply

    [url=http://zmkshop.ru/]двутавр нестандартной длины[/url]

  • apetamin-p ohne Rezept in Antwerpen bestellen/ 13.08.2024Reply

    farmaci disponibile senza prescrizione a Venezia Arena Fürth Koop medicijnen online tegen de beste prijzen in Nederland

  • clarinex ohne Verschreibung erhältlich in Österreich/ 29.08.2024Reply

    Waar medicijnen zonder medisch voorschrift te vinden Hikma Moquegua medicijnen kopen in Nederland
    veilig en snel

  • ms word мәтіндік редакторы практикалық тапсырмалар/ 06.09.2024Reply

    как создать nft картинку, 3d nft что это қош келдің әз
    наурыз тәрбие сағаты слайд,
    армысың әз наурыз тәрбие сағаты аңыздың ақыры тест, аңыздың ақыры қысқаша мазмұны мулдем скачать,
    много тебя скачать

  • eczeem opvlammende allergieën/ 13.09.2024Reply

    What’s Taking place i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have discovered It positively helpful and
    it has helped me out loads. I am hoping to contribute
    & assist other users like its helped me. Good job.

  • Les services supplémentaires offerts lors de l'achat de fluisedal en ligne/ 16.09.2024Reply

    consulta il prezzo di farmaci con prescrizione medica a Catania Marksans
    Saint-Brieuc médicaments en ligne sans ordonnance

  • өзбек халқының салт дәстүрі презентация/ 03.10.2024Reply

    ыбырай алтынсарин білім туралы нақыл сөздер, ыбырай алтынсарин туралы эпиграф жк шыгыс астана,
    жк шыгыс астана отзывы аспан неге көгілдір, аспан әлеміне саяхат
    временная работа в степногорске,
    работа в степногорске для женщин

  • ресей мемлекеттік құрылымы/ 07.10.2024Reply

    499 бұйрық 2020, 499 бұйрық 2021 әдепті сөйлеу мәдениеті, сөйлеу әдебі дегеніміз не аспазшы туралы тақпақ балабақшада, мен
    аспазшы боламын ғарыш қалай игерілді 3 сынып жаратылыстану

  • кызылша ауруы сурет/ 10.10.2024Reply

    крид одеколон цена, крид авентус
    100 мл цена табиғат дауысы скачать, керемет күйлер скачать барқыт тау жасыл дала морфологиялық талдау, басқару сөзіне морфологиялық талдау алтын орданы қай хан билеген тұста ісләм діні үстемдік алды?, қай
    жылы қазақ даласында жергілікті

  • м әуезовтың 1916 жылғы оқиғаны суреттейтін пьесасы/ 11.10.2024Reply

    планета интернет магазин,
    магазин мечта караганда 45 квартал туры на новый год
    из астаны, туры на новый год 2023 из астаны тілек туралы мақал, рахмет туралы мақал мәтелдер карта
    крест ленорман

  • камень знака зодиака лев 6 августа/ 21.10.2024Reply

    точный гороскоп лошадь кольцо в подарок к чему снится
    к чему снится злая бойцовская собака
    к чему снится живая родственница мертвой к чему снится добрый
    волк девушке

  • приснилась битая кошка/ 23.10.2024Reply

    период и частота формула, период частота калькулятор
    таро на похудение значения учеба в университете сонник
    пик любви аршан козерог есть ли порча на
    замужество

  • бәсентиін руының шежіресі схема/ 27.10.2024Reply

    түс жору жігіт көрсе, түсінде ер адам көрсе не болады абкдс прививка қазақша, балаларға
    екпе егу презентация стихи пермских поэтов для
    детей, гимн пермского края скачать 200
    тенге монета размер, 200 тенге монета тираж

  • культура древних племен на территории казахстана/ 31.10.2024Reply

    энжио когда применять, энжио норма расхода на 1
    га природное наследие казахстана,
    приведите примеры объектов мирового природного наследия.
    кубизм бағытының негізін қалаушы,
    орта ғасырдағы бейнелеу өнері бастауыш сынып оқыту әдістемесі, бастауыш білім беру педагогикасы мен әдістемесі

  • Bennett/ 31.10.2024Reply

    I’m really enjoying the design and layout of your site.
    It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more
    enjoyable for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire
    out a designer to create your theme? Fantastic work!

  • все время снятся умершие/ 14.11.2024Reply

    что означает карта таро 15 аркан какие камни подходят близнецам
    мужчинам по гороскопу молитвы о детях и внуках на учебу
    что если снится что едешь на машине за рулем амулет гермеса
    трисмегиста

  • Medikamente ohne Rezept in Deutschland erhältlich Leidapharm Gand (Gent)/ 20.11.2024Reply

    où acheter du médicaments sans ordonnance Combix Tielt
    Medikamentenpreise in Frankreich

  • к чему снится выдавливание прыща на лице/ 30.11.2024Reply

    Pretty! This has been an incredibly wonderful post.
    Thank you for providing these details.

Leave a Comment