The Great Acting Blog: “Actors Need To Reclaim Acting – Lessons From EA Dupont’s Piccadilly”
EA Dupont’s silent era masterpiece, Piccadilly, is set in a fashionable London nightclub, and is about an exotic dancer, played by Anna May Wong, whose routines lead to her becoming the toast of Jazz-Age London. She also becomes the erotic obssesion of the her boss Valentine Wilmot (played by Jameson Thomas), which in turn, pushes the nose of his former lover and star dancer, Mabel Greenfield (Gilda Gray), out of joint, setting off a chain of events leading to tragedy. Piccadilly features some simply breathtaking cinematography, which your eyes will hardly believe, and if anyone is any doubt about the credentials of early British cinema, then they need not look any further than Dupont’s film. Joyously, we are also treated to an early Charles Laughton performance, credited as “nightclub diner”, where he complains about a dirty plate. However, it was by the acting generally, that I was piqued – I would not be exaggerating to say that I have simply never seen so many masterful performances all in the same film.
I could single out the sheer intensity of King Hou Chang, but that would be unfair to the provocative and piquant Anna May Wong, and to the grace and technical execellence of Thomas and Gray. The acting in this film is beautiful. The performances are made up of small moments possessed with a perfectly distilled meaning, serving a very precise purpose, and executed with a consummate control. In some respects, a silent film gives us a clearer view to the actor’s work, similar to when watching a subtitled foreign film, because we don’t have potential distraction of the sound of what the actors are saying, and which is particularly distracting when the actor speaks the lines falsly. Certainly in Piccadilly, some of the power of the performances would have been lost if we had been able to hear what the actors were saying – it was just such a rich experience observing their movements and facial expressions. As with all great performances, we are treated to witnessing the truth of the actor’s personality, and that was no different in this film, where the honesty and lack of self-consciousness meant that the actors revealed themselves, made themselves vulnerable, which, in turn, rendered the film’s love triangle truly heartbreaking – a human being defending their position with everything they’ve got, is indeed a powerful sight. In the end, the performances in Piccadilly attain the highest point in acting; they show us that the human face can be poetic.
All of which left me confused. Surely the acting in silent cinema was no match for our all-dominant contemporary “naturalism”? Aren’t pre-mid 20th century actors supposed to be false, “theatrical”, mechanical? And yet, Piccadilly, and other films from that era, have proved to be such rich viewing experiences, especially when compared to today’s work, so much of which seems trivial, cynical, superficial and self-serving (I’ve found this to be even more the case in theatre). It’s generally thought that acting changed around the middle of the last century, that what had gone on before that period was no longer acceptable – a new, apparently idealistic new generation of teachers and directors, ushered in a new modern era of “realism”. It’s hard to see how acting has changed in that period, but what is certainly true is that actors have become completely dominated by directors, and subservient to teachers, even to the extent that the actor himself is marginalised within his own performance (eg – directors or teachers getting the acclaim for great work done by an actor). More broadly speaking, the stature of actors has diminished, with less of them now in control of companies, or even being perceived of as capable of running companies (would the establishment of an institution such as the National Theatre be put in an actors hands today?). Donald Wolfitt set up his own touring company because nobody would give him a chance to play Hamlet, and in early cinema, there was no director: the cinematographer took are of the pictures, and the actors took care of the acting. Could it be then, that there never was anything wrong with the way acting was done, but that it was attacked by directors and teachers in order to create the space for them to have careers, ie – directors and teachers shove actors off their own work, then take responsibility for it, and, voila!?
Masterpieces like Piccadilly, prove that there never was anything wrong with the way acting was done, infact, there is strong evidence to suggest that perfromances were (and are) generally stronger when the actor left alone to get on with his work, in the best way he sees fit, taking responsibility for all aspects of it.
James Devereaux/ 12.07.2012
Oh wow, would love to have seen the film in such a context, especially with accordian. Glad you’re a fan of Piccadilly too. Many thanks for your comment, Andrew.
Mame/ 29.12.2022
I love Anna and now am dying to see this film. Another of my favorite actresses is Setsuko Hara one of the best actresses who worked with Ozu and Kurosawa. All she has to do is smile and the tears flow. She has such inner work on each transition.This is a wonderful blog. I am getting inspired by your writing and encouragement.
jazz instrumental music/ 22.12.2023
jazz instrumental music
atectura günstig kaufen apotheken deutschland/ 13.08.2024
médicaments pour une vie sans soucis Orion Reuver est-il
possible d’obtenir du médicaments sans ordonnance à Genève
médicaments sans ordonnance Espagne Egis El Doncello/ 18.08.2024
ordenar medicamentos en línea de manera segura Roemmers Castronno medicamentos disponible en Brasil
amlobesyl zonder voorschrift online te koop/ 21.08.2024
Comprimidos genéricos baratos Qualigen Spijkenisse Wie bekomme ich Medikamente ohne ärztliche Verschreibung
Precio del medicamentos en Valparaíso Pharmapar Bussum/ 22.08.2024
medicamentos disponible sin receta en Suiza Cassara Brunssum kaufe Medikamente in Spanien
zosec kaufen ohne Rezept - apotheke Vergleich/ 23.08.2024
Comprare farmaci senza prescrizione medica in Italia Lupin Santa Marta Achat de médicaments pour les traitements de longue
durée
Acheter omesec sans ordonnance/ 28.08.2024
kan je medicijnen krijgen zonder medisch voorschrift Amneal Caldas consulta il prezzo
di farmaci con prescrizione medica a Napoli
Allergiemedikament gegen Juckreiz bei Hunden/ 12.09.2024
I think this is one of the most vital information for me.
And i’m glad reading your article. But want to remark on few
general things, The web site style is wonderful, the articles is really
nice : D. Good job, cheers
шығыс түрік қағанаты шаруашылығы/ 15.09.2024
мұрын бітелуін емдеу жолдары,
мұрынға ет өсу белгілері мемлекеттік қызмет және жемқорлық, мемлекеттік қызмет істері
агенттігі шымкент дыбысты қалай естиміз, дыбыс
толқындары ауада қалай таралады шын кескін деген не
Meilleur prix pour la furosemide en ligne en Belgique/ 17.09.2024
Puedes comprar medicamentos en línea sin receta médica Germed Balboa medicijnen online bestellen: gemakkelijk en vertrouwd
ертіс өзені географиялық орны/ 17.09.2024
кинотеатр алматы мега, мега кинотеатр
алматы расписание сейфуллина на завтра карточка
т2 это, личная карточка т2 где взять 4р маркетинг, комплекс
маркетинга 4p пример шаш гигиенасы,
шаш пен тырнақ гигиенасына
қойылатын гигиеналық талаптарды көрсетіңіз
отбасылық ғұрыптар қмж 5 сынып/ 19.09.2024
1 айлық бала жөтелсе не істеу керек, 6 айлық бала жөтелсе не істеу керек жан
сырымды бір өзіңе ғана аккорды, бір
көргеннен өзіңді ремикс скачать шаттық шеңбері жол ережесі
табигатпен адам омири бирликте, табиғат туралы әңгіме
таможенные платежи и их виды рк/ 01.10.2024
арқан тартыс, арқан тартыс ойыны сабақ жоспары уақыт қадірі алмас темірбай ғарышта әңгіме 4 сынып, шексіз ғарыш
әлемі функция y=kx, линейная функция
медеу сәрсеке қаныш сәтбаев роман эссе әдеби сын/ 07.10.2024
ауыл атаулары казакстан, ауыл атаулары қ әріпінен басталатын
жаратылыстану 4 сынып ктж, ктж 4 сынып әдебиеттік оқу алунит что
это, алунит дезодорант хайырлы жұмыс сұрау
дұғасы, алладан жәрдем сұрау намазы
Celllucare Reviews/ 26.10.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Info to that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-actors-need-to-reclaim/ […]
Pretty Gaming Casino ค่ายคาสิโน มาตรฐานสากล/ 26.10.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-actors-need-to-reclaim/ […]
молитва св ефрема сирина в великий пост/ 01.11.2024
у мужа есть ребенок сонник к чему сниться сон
когда в тебя стреляют а ты живая к чему
снится то что мою лучшую подругу убивают
во сне
391 значение числа к чему снится
что ударил незнакомый мужчина
подработки в костроме днем/ 02.11.2024
онлайн работа на дому без вложений
вакансии удаленная через интернет подработка в
обнинске свежие вакансии от прямых работодателей уборка
домов квартир подработка вакансии работы на дому разместить
cat888/ 13.11.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Information to that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-actors-need-to-reclaim/ […]
сайт рефератов и курсовых работ бесплатно/ 16.11.2024
оқу мотивациясын анықтау тесті, мотивациялық
сауалнама отбасы туралы макал мателдер қоян
жылы туылғандардың мінезі,
қоян жылы нені білдіреді список запрещенных товаров для ввоза
в казахстан 2022, что можно ввозить
в казахстан 2022
филология университеты казахстана/ 16.11.2024
карта ойнау карталарында иә жоқ деп айтатын онлайн жүктілік ормандарды қалпына келтіру, не себепті өрттен
кейін орманның қалпына келуі үшін ұзақ уақыт
қажет барлық мұхиттар, мұхит бөліктері мейрамдар, қаңтар айындағы мерекелер 2023
เว็บพนันออนไลน์เกาหลี/ 20.11.2024
… [Trackback]
[…] Find More here on that Topic: jamesdevereaux.com/the-great-acting-blog-actors-need-to-reclaim/ […]