The Great Acting Blog: “A Response To Otar Iosseliani’s Comments On Actors’ Aura”
“I cant stand intimate scenes in cinema….because every human being has an aura which is hard to penetrate. Professional actors imagine that it’s part of their job to allow the director or other actors to penetrate their aura and enter into a totally unnatural contact with somebody they don’t know.
Which is also why I consider it completely shameless to have very tight close-ups of people because the so-called “actor” cannot hide who he is, he’s too close to us and he becomes distanced from the character. He becomes an actual person, an individual with all his considerations. And I have no desire to have an actual person on-screen. I want it to be a character, always a character.” – Otar Iosseliani.
I don’t agree with much of what Iosseliani says here, especially about close-ups, because, for me, close-ups are not necessarily intimate. However, what did pique me, were his comments about “aura” and character. It’s worth pointing out to those unfamiliar with Iosseliani’s work, that typically he uses “non-actors” in his films, whose general lack of technique creates an awkwardness, and this awkwardness demarcates the performance, thus the character is always present.* Further, the “non-actor” is usually more inhibited than the experienced actor, and is therefore less apt to “show”.
But what does Iosseliani mean when he speaks of “aura”? Well, aura, in my view, means diginity – people with an aura, act with the dignity, it’s their dignity which gives them an aura. And dignity is about self-control, self-respect, acting with conviction, and behaving honourably (Chishu Ryu immediately springs to mind). The character is always present if the actor remains true to the aesthetic integrity of the work at hand, which is to say; committing fully to the actions called forth by the scene, and excluding everything else. Whenever an actor supplies an emotion which has not been organically produced by his attempts to do the action of the scene, such as when those people with a knack for making themselves cry decide to turn on the waterworks for no other reason than that they can, the aesthetic integrity of the piece is violated, the illusion is shattered, suddenly the audience become aware of the actor exposing himself, and the dignity of not only the actor, but of the audience and the whole dramatic interchange, is lost (typically, in a desparate scramble for self-respect, this exposure manifests itself as admiration for the actor’s technique by the audience, and for the actor’s part, he speaks about the moment as “liberating”, and, “a breakthrough”).
The intent to remain true to the aesthetic integrity of the scene, is not the same as the intent to expose oneself. All this stuff about actors “going further” or “making themselves vulnerable”, points to a gross misunderstanding of what acting actually is, and is part of the trend in our wider culture to just let it all hang loose. In the end however, this transparency leads to trivial acting: because in letting us see everything, the actor expresses nothing. Great acting requires discipline and restraint, precision and control, artistic choices are made, only that which is essential is offered. A truthful performance, that is, one where the actor is true to the work and to himself, is always dignified, always mysterious, and, to use Iosseliani’s language, never penetrates the aura of the actor. And, for the actor, the character does not exist other than as a reference for analysis, but by only sticking to the actions of the scene and cutting away everything else, the actor’s performance becomes hi-definition, deliberate, and as a result it would seem, as Iosseliani would have it, as though the character is always present – the actor is ignoring those parts of himself which are not required for the scene, certainly his quotidian troubles have been left behind. This is also how the actor may reveal the truth of his own personality, while at the same time, maintaining the essential mystery of himself.
James Devereaux/ 06.04.2012
hahaha, yes, I suppose the word "expose" can have many different connotations depending on the context. Glad you concur with the post, and many thanks for the positive feedback.
Save on diclowell with Online Discounts/ 23.07.2024
I am genuinely pleased to glance at this webpage posts which includes
plenty of valuable information, thanks for providing these kinds of statistics.
médicaments sans prescription : Les risques potentiels CristerS Karlsruhe/ 05.08.2024
Online-Kauf von Medikamenten in Brüssel Polipharm San Andrés médicaments pour une meilleure santé
comprar dilatrane en España legalmente/ 06.08.2024
Acheter médicaments en ligne en toute confidentialité
Polipharm Davos acheter des médicaments similaires
medicamentos sin receta en Suiza Arena Palma de Mallorca/ 17.08.2024
Medikamente rezeptfrei erhältlich in bestimmten Ländern nepenthes Enkhuizen Medikamente Kauf in München
go88-games.com/ 18.08.2024
Go88 đã nhanh chóng trở thành một trong những nền tảng giải trí trực tuyến được yêu thích nhất tại Việt Nam
Website: https://go88-games.com/
8day-casino.com/ 18.08.2024
8DAY là nhà cái uy tín, mang đến trải nghiệm cá cược trực tuyến đa dạng và hấp dẫn cho người chơi.
Website: https://8day-casino.com/
Kubet/ 19.08.2024
Kubet la nha cai noi tieng voi cac tro choi ca cuoc da dang va chuong trinh khuyen mai hap dan.
Website: https://kubet-casino.org/
médicaments sans prescription médicale au Maroc Biogaran Schaesberg/ 20.08.2024
Bestellung von Medikamente online aufgeben DOC Aerschot (Aarschot) acquisto di farmaci online
какую молитву читать перед сном православному/ 21.08.2024
молитва на ночь перед сном короткая на русском ребенку во сне выпадали зубы к чему это снится женщине
пресвятая мати божия благая богородица не остави нас своею вечною
и доброю молитвою
как рассчитать свои арканы по дате др 17 октября какой знак
зодиака
Go88/ 23.08.2024
Go88 la cong game bai doi thuong xin nhat Viet Nam trong nam 2024. Ngay tu khi ra mat thi truong toi nay, Go88.com da khang dinh duoc vi the cua mot san choi ca cuoc truc tuyen hang dau. website: https://go88club.us/
medicijnen zonder recept aanschaffen Medicus Cimitile/ 27.08.2024
Freiverkauf von Medikamenten in der Schweiz galpharm Catacaos Medikamente ohne Rezept:
Legalität und Risiken
Typhu88/ 29.08.2024
Typhu88 mang den cho nguoi choi mot trai nghiem ca cuoc an toan, thu vi va day hap dan. Hay cung kham pha the gioi giai tri dinh cao voi Typhu 88, noi moi nhu cau ca cuoc cua ban deu duoc dap ung mot cach hoan hao. Website: https://typhu88-vn.com/
achat en ligne de médicaments à Bruxelles qualigen Morges/ 29.08.2024
Plaats een bestelling voor medicijnen online lyfis
Saint-Ghislain medicijnen online bestellen in Nederland
THABET/ 30.08.2024
THABET nha cai cung cap cac san pham game online nhu xoc dia, baccrat, xo so live, ca cuoc the thao, ca cuoc bong da….
website: https://thabet-vn.com/
если снятся одежда красный цвет/ 30.08.2024
гороскоп между девой и весами
8 марта приснилось 8 аркан таро как предназначение
к чему снится убить ножом людей
совместимость по работе козерога
GO88/ 31.08.2024
Go88 la thien duong game bai doi thuong uy tin so 1 Viet Nam. Link trang chu chinh thuc Go88.com, Dang ky nhan thuong +50K. website: https://mkstalin.net/
8kbet/ 07.09.2024
8KBET – Nhà cái game bài đổi thưởng đã khẳng định vị thế là một trong những thiên đường giải trí uy tín hàng đầu tại Việt Nam hiện nay. Gần đây đã ra mắt thêm tên miền chính thức 8kbet.international để phục vụ cộng đồng game thủ Việt Nam.
12bet/ 08.09.2024
12bet nam trong danh sach dia chi ca cuoc truc tuyen uy tin hang dau hien nay. He thong chinh thuc ra mat thi truong ca cuoc sau khi da co dinh huong ro rang ve chien thuat phat trien. Sau nhieu nam hoat dong, thuong hieu ke tren hien phat trien he thong ve tinh rong khap Chau A. http://12betsg.asia/
beste allergie verlichting neussprays/ 13.09.2024
Hi there, this weekend is nice designed for me, since
this point in time i am reading this impressive educational piece of writing
here at my house.
hoeveel antihistaminica kan ik dagelijks nemen/ 13.09.2024
Excellent blog you’ve got here.. It’s hard to find high quality writing
like yours nowadays. I honestly appreciate individuals
like you! Take care!!
telfast 180 mg koop generieke geneesmiddelen legaal in Belgie/ 14.09.2024
I am truly delighted to read this weblog posts which consists of tons of useful information, thanks for providing such
information.
diphenhydramine di aumento di peso/ 14.09.2024
Thanks for any other great article. The place else could anybody
get that kind of information in such an ideal approach of writing?
I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I’m on the look for such information.
789Win/ 15.09.2024
789Win duoc biet den la mot nha cai co lich su phat trien rat lau doi va co tieng tam tren thi truong ca cuoc toan the gioi. Diem den nay duoc thanh lap tai Philippines va da nhanh chong lay duoc su quan tam tu nhieu game thu ngay tu khi ra mat thi truong Website: https://789win.energy/
қазақстандағы қола дәуірі кезеңдері/ 15.09.2024
фиксатор для пальца руки цена,
лангет на палец руки алматы сулпак атырау телефон, сулпак атырау
авангард телефон фрибет за регистрацию, букмекерская контора бонус при регистрации без депозита казахстан бел рубли в дирхамы
тжб 5 сынып қазақ тілі 2 тоқсан жауаптарымен 2020/ 19.09.2024
өскен ай мен үйдегі ақша тундырып тастаған өткен күнім текст, тоңдырып тастаған өткен
күнім 2 скачать витамин в12 олимп цена, витамин в12 цена
в ампулах бонусная система
для клиентов, sagi приложение
под прямыми расходами на производство понимаются/ 26.09.2024
бір стақан судағы жұмыртқа арқылы бұзылуды кетіру әдебиет сабағын оқыту әдістері, әдебиетті жоғары
мектепте оқыту әдістемесі су өзгерістен қорықпайды, удз қазақша презентация nike defy all day
отзывы, nike купить
photojournalism and depression/ 20.10.2024
Hey would you mind letting me know which web host you’re utilizing?
I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different internet browsers and
I must say this blog loads a lot faster then most. Can you suggest a good
web hosting provider at a reasonable price? Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!
Sunwin/ 21.10.2024
Sunwin la cong game bai top 1 Viet Nam. Sun Win cung cap nhieu tro choi hot, do hoa sac net va nhung chuong trinh khuyen mai nhan code hap dan nhat thi truong. sunwinclub.asia
Medikamente ohne Rezept in Düsseldorf zu erwerben Mepha Pharma Glaris/ 27.10.2024
Precios de medicamentos en Estados Unidos Zydus Poortugaal precio del medicamentos con receta
кухонный работник подработка спб/ 02.11.2024
сайт фрилансеров бесплатный задания работа тинькофф на дому по интернету фурманов подработка ежедневная оплата оператор 1с удаленно вакансии
готовые работы на дистанционное обучение/ 03.11.2024
рабочий дом вакансии работа авито вакансии подработка курск как быстро и
незаконно заработать денег дом работа
тоска
W88/ 06.11.2024
W88 la nha cai duoc thanh lap tu nam 2013 duoi su bao ho cua Pagcor, Isle of Man Gambling Supervision Commission, Cagayan and Freeport va NCSC. Website: https://w88ct.com
как зарабатывать деньги в интернете с нуля/ 12.11.2024
подработка в нововоронеже с ежедневной оплатой иностранные сайты
фриланса для художников работа на дому в санкт петербурге швеей
васенко дом быта часы работы
Comprar medicamentos Stada Villars-sur-Glâne/ 18.11.2024
Kauf von Medikamente Mylan in Deutschland Leidapharm Manizales medicamentos en venta en Ecuador sin prescripción